"The Park Service has this problem of balancing the mandate to
preserve the ruins and the mandate to allow the public to enjoy them.
Maybe that's an impossible paradox."
In Search of the Old Ones by David Roberts
I must admit I've been struggling with this paradox recently. Two things have made me think about it more than in the past. One is my recent opportunity to see some really wonderful, and seldom seen, Native American rock art sites. One of the sites I discovered on my own. I don't even think the Park Service is aware of it or has cataloged it (although I've reached out to them), and it's really a unique site. I feel a sense of responsibility to keep all these sites secret. The second is when I was recently contacted by the Park Service and asked to remove a photo I had posted on Flickr. Their request went something like this: By popularizing and publicizing sacred places (such as Native American rock art sites), very real detrimental effects can occur. They go on to say that this particular site is closed and considered sacred (although there is no indication or signage that the site is closed).
On most things, I strongly agree with the NPS. These sites are fragile and when they're gone, they are gone forever. There's no getting them back. They fade with time so they are slowly disappearing as I type this. We must do whatever is reasonable and necessary to preserve and document them. That includes never sharing location information on social media. I do my best to keep the location of these sites hidden.
But what about educating National Park visitors about rock art and the Native Americans who were here before us? What about cultivating a sense of awe and wonder about these unique cultural resources? Is that "popularizing" or simply educating? Is pretending that these sites don't exist and ignoring them the best way to protect them? I have no good answers, other than, to me, educating people about them while not publicizing their location seems like a good approach. So I've gone full circle in my thinking and come back to where I started: It's an impossible paradox. Oh, by the way, I guess this blog is not on the NPS radar. I've not been asked to take down photos of this site that I posted here. Check it out while you still can, but don't go looking for the site! And I think you will agree, there's nothing on my post that gives away site location.
So I'll stop blabbing and share some photos with you of a recent find. As far as I know, this site is not closed or sacred, although who knows? It's another site that I doubt the Park Service is even aware of. This location is exciting to me for a couple reasons. I just happened to stumble across it on my own, which always makes a site special (vs. someone telling you the location). But more importantly, this is east Joshua Tree. I post about this area all the time. It's my favorite part of the Park because it is so isolated and secluded. It also has almost no rock art! There's only one spot I know of (called Monolith Alcove) where anyone has found rock art in this entire area. So it's really special and significant to find something.
A great day for a hike, with blue skies and enough clouds to make things interesting!
I spot this large, dome-shaped boulder off in the distance. It takes me off my planned track to the area I am hoping to explore, but it looks to good to pass up! As I get closer, I can see what appears to be two alcoves at the base. The alcove openings look a little like eyes, giving the formation the look of a big head or skull. Very cool!
Closer view |
Closer still - profile view |
The alcove is roomy, comfortable, and provides wonderful views. It would be a shady retreat in the summer, and an escape from the elements any time of year.
I take a moment to examine the walls, not expecting to find anything. I've probably climbed in nearly 100 alcoves in this area and never found any rock art, with just one exception. But to my near disbelief, I can make out some very faint pictographs!
Enhancing with dStretch, there's not doubt about it. Looking even closer, there might be some dark pictograph forms on the center right and lower right (small sunburst, perhaps?), along with the clearly visible red pictograph markings. The rock surface of the alcove looks significantly eroded. I'm guessing there was a lot more here many years ago.
I notice another faint pictograph. Can you see it?
Here it is highlighted a little using dStretch:
Looks like a yoni symbol. Not an abundance of pictographs, but finding anything in this area is very significant! In the very unlikely event you run across this site, please leave it exactly as you find it. Don't touch the walls of the alcove, and "take only pictures / leave only footprints". And here's a teaser. I still had time to continue exploring after finding this site. What I found later on this same hike is even more amazing. To be continued!
Linking with Skywatch Friday.
Thanks for stopping by!!